Some college “Career Services” are a joke

indexI have twins attending excellent universities in Philadelphia.  But it was disappointing to see their resumes that were approved by the schools’ Career Services area.

After talking more with my kids about what the Career Services are providing, I’ve come to realize that it’s not much of anything useful. Where are the real-life tools they need to land a job after graduation — or even an internship for that matter?

Initially I thought it was my experience with only these two schools but it’s not.  My kids have sent their friends to reach out to me and take a look at their resumes.  Different schools — top-notch schools — are falling short to prep our students in this area.  I asked one gal what her Career Services department did to help with her resume and she told me they handed her a hard copy of a resume template.  That’s it!  And it was garbage.

In my conversations with these students I’m finding that not only are they not spending enough time on how to craft a solid resume and treat it as a working document throughout their careers, but they’re not touching on many of the fundamentals of networking and interviewing.  All but one student I spoke with didn’t know to research a company before the interview.  How much more basic can you get?

We’ve been in a job rut since 2008.  Experienced professionals are taking lower paying jobs to stay afloat financially.  People who have planned to retire can’t and are working longer.  With so many graduates each year, how will these students be able to get an edge so they can create their own career opportunities?

The students — our future — need the academic world to allow career and business professionals into the classroom to put these antiquated ideas in the grave.

It’s time for the professors to move aside and allow business leaders, hiring managers, career coaches and resume writers in the classrooms.  They can lay the foundation of covering all the critical areas of the job search:

  • how to craft a resume
  • how to write a concise yet meaningful cover letter
  • interviewing skills and fundamentals
  • networking basics — do’s and don’ts

I know so many intelligent and overall great young people who are getting ready to launch in May and I’m worried for them.

I know there has to be schools who are doing it right — I just wish there was a way for it to be universal.

If you have experience with colleges who are doing this right — please let me hear about it so I can have a glimmer of hope for our future.


Hate to break it to you but…

You’re not a guru.  You’re not a god or goddess. You’re not a rainmaker.  And no, you’re not a rockstar either.  Not seeing many Steven Tyler-types traveling in the HR and career circles.

Be flattered and humbled if a colleague uses one of these words to describe you to others but when you use these descriptors in your LinkedIn, Twitter or other online profiles, ask yourself this: “How is my character being perceived by others? How am I being perceived by others?”

I wrote about the perception of recruiters and hiring managers on wearing diamond rings on a job interview to make the point of leaving only your skills, qualifications and character to be evaluated.  In other words, don’t let yourself be vulnerable to someone else’s (potentially false) judgment about you.  The same applies to your resume and online professional profiles.

Confidence vs. arrogance
There’s a fine line between confidence and arrogance.  Be confident and proudly share your expertise using real words that quantify the accomplishments and results from your skills and experience — words that people can relate to.  You may not be arrogant but if you call yourself a guru or rainmaker, how do you expect to be perceived?  These words scream “arrogance!” and that’s not an attractive character trait.

The successful mix
Whether you’re in a job search or just great at what you do, be real!  People want to work with folks who are on top of their game professionally but people also want to work with folks who have upstanding character and integrity.  Nothing beats authenticity and confidence with a splash of humility.

So please, I’m begging you!  Lose the narcissistic jargon and let folks get to know you for who you are and what you bring to the table.  Always remember that perception is reality.  If your online persona is perceived to be brash and egotistical, then you are brash and egotistical.

What do you think?  Feel free to share your thoughts.

Photo credit Yuri Samoilov